Security Guide
Security Guard vs. Off-Duty Police Officer: How to Choose
Security guards and off-duty police officers can both stand at the same door, but they are different roles with different authority, different rules and different costs. The right choice depends on the site’s risk, the duties the post requires and what the local police department allows. This guide explains when each fits, how authority differs, what drives cost and how off-duty programs typically work.
What Each Option Is
A security guard is a private officer employed by a licensed security company. The officer is licensed and trained under state law, works under the site’s Post Orders and reports to the security company’s supervisors.
An off-duty police officer is an active, sworn officer working a private assignment outside regular police shifts. The officer remains subject to the department’s rules on outside employment, which can limit where, when and how the officer works. Many departments run these assignments through a formal program rather than allowing officers to arrange them on their own.
A retired law enforcement officer is a third option. Retired officers bring years of police experience to a post, but they work as private security officers and are licensed under state rules for security officers.
How Authority Differs
Private security officers have no police powers. They observe, deter, report and enforce the client’s property rules. Any authority to detain a person or use force is limited by state law, which varies from state to state. When a situation calls for police action, a security officer calls the police.
Off-duty police officers keep police powers only as their department and local law allow. Departments set the terms. In New York City, for example, the NYPD’s Paid Details brochure states that officers in the program carry full law enforcement powers, are expected to perform police-related duties only, do not carry or issue summonses and remain subject at all times to NYPD rules and standards of conduct. Officers who encounter an arrest situation call for an on-duty or Paid Detail supervisor to decide the course of action. Other departments set different rules, so the terms should be confirmed with the department before an assignment begins.
Retired officers work under the same authority as any private security officer. Their experience shapes how they handle a post, but on a private assignment they work as security officers, not as police.
When a Security Guard Fits
A licensed security officer is the right choice for most retail stores, corporate offices, residential buildings and hospitality settings. Security officers typically fit where:
- The main concerns are shoplifting, trespass, disorderly visitors or access control
- The post requires client service, front desk duties, patrols or detailed reporting
- Coverage is needed every day, on a fixed schedule, with the same officers on post
- The site wants officers trained on its own procedures and Post Orders
Security officers can also be armed where the risk calls for it. The Armed vs. Unarmed Security Guards guide explains when each fits.
When an Off-Duty Police Officer Fits
An off-duty officer is a narrower tool. It may be appropriate where a sworn officer’s presence is part of the security plan, such as:
- Large-crowd events and product launches
- High-value merchandise movements or deliveries
- Executive or VIP visits
- Sites with a serious incident history after a risk review
- Traffic assignments and other duties suited to a sworn officer
Off-duty officers are generally a poor fit for posts that require customer service, front desk work or duties outside police work, because department rules often limit what an officer may do on an outside assignment.
How Off-Duty Police Programs Work
Each department sets its own rules. Two official examples show how these programs are commonly structured.
New York City. According to the NYPD’s Paid Details brochure, the Paid Detail Unit coordinates the department’s program for off-duty uniformed security work, and the brochure describes it as the only authorized program for uniformed NYPD off-duty employment. Organizations apply as vendors and submit a contract and a certificate of insurance for the Police Commissioner’s approval, with an estimated preparation time of about eight weeks. Officers are drawn from a database of volunteers, and the NYPD determines the minimum coverage and any supervisory coverage needed. The brochure lists security companies among the organizations excluded from participating as vendors.
Miami. A 2020 City of Miami audit of the Miami Police Department’s Extra Duty Employment Program describes a program administered by the department’s Special Events Unit. The audit describes permanent jobs, such as supermarkets, banks and restaurants, temporary jobs and special events. Outside employers pay for the officers’ time, either directly or through the city depending on the type of job, and also pay the city an hourly administrative fee for each officer, with a minimum charge.
What Drives the Cost
Off-duty and security officer coverage are priced in different ways, and the drivers are worth understanding before comparing them.
Off-duty officers. The department usually sets the terms. The NYPD brochure ties the officer’s hourly rate to rank and adds a 10 percent administrative charge payable to the City of New York, and the Miami audit describes an hourly administrative fee for each officer. Minimum hours, supervisor requirements for larger details, prepayment for some events and the number of officers the department requires can all raise the total.
Security officers. A security company’s bill rate reflects the officer’s wage, payroll taxes, insurance, licensing, training, supervision and call-out coverage. Officer classification, armed or unarmed status, schedule, overtime and holiday coverage shape the final number. The McCray Security Guard Cost Guide explains these drivers in more detail.
Total program cost. An off-duty officer can be the right tool for a short, high-risk window, while a security officer is usually more practical for daily coverage. Many sites combine the two, with security officers on daily posts and sworn or retired officers added for specific risks.
How McCray Coordinates Off-Duty and Retired Officer Coverage
McCray assigns officers through its Officer Classification Program, which runs from Tier I to Tier IV. Tier IV covers active law enforcement officers on agency-approved off-duty status. Tier III covers retired law enforcement officers with at least 20 years of sworn service, who hold an armed license, complete Tier II training and qualify with firearms each year.
McCray coordinates off-duty officer coverage where the local department allows it, verifying sworn status and agency training before assignment. Where a department does not permit off-duty work through a private security company, McCray assigns Tier III retired law enforcement officers instead. In New York City, off-duty NYPD officers are booked through the NYPD Paid Detail Unit, and McCray provides Tier III retired officers.
Every assignment runs under site-specific Post Orders, with GPS clock-in, incident and shift reports in the same format in every market, and the McCray Operations Desk answering 24/7/365 in English or Spanish. More detail is available on the Off-Duty Police Officer Services page.
Common Questions
Is an Off-Duty Police Officer Better Than a Security Guard?
Not in every case. An off-duty officer brings sworn authority and police training, which can matter for events, high-value movements or sites with a serious incident history. A security officer is usually the better fit for daily coverage, customer-facing posts and duties outside police work.
Do Off-Duty Police Officers Have Arrest Powers on a Private Assignment?
It depends on the department and local law. In the NYPD Paid Detail program, for example, officers carry full law enforcement powers but are expected to perform police-related duties only and call for a supervisor in an arrest situation. Other departments set different terms.
Do Security Guards Have Police Powers?
No. Private security officers have no police powers. Any authority to detain a person or use force is limited by state law, and security officers call the police when a situation requires police action.
Can McCray Provide Off-Duty Police Officers in Every City?
Availability depends on the local department. McCray coordinates off-duty coverage where the department allows it and assigns Tier III retired law enforcement officers where it does not.
Request a Security Assessment
The right mix of security officers, off-duty officers and retired officers depends on the site. McCray will review the location and its risks and recommend the right coverage for each post.
Request a Security Assessment or call (833) 832-6647.
Sources
- New York City Police Department, Paid Details brochure (BM 258, 06-16): https://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/downloads/pdf/public_information/nypd-258_paid_details_2016-06-16.pdf
- City of Miami, Audit of the Miami Police Department Extra Duty Employment Program, Report No. 20-03 (January 7, 2020): https://www.miami.gov/files/sharedassets/public/v/1/internal-audits/reports/2019-2020/20-03_audit_of_mpd_extra_duty_employment_program-final.pdf
- McCray, Off-Duty Police Officer Services (link target confirmed): https://mccraygp.com/services/off-duty-police-officers/
- McCray, Armed vs. Unarmed Security Guards: How to Choose (link target confirmed): https://mccraygp.com/armed-vs-unarmed-security-guards/
- McCray, How Much Do Security Guards Cost? (link target confirmed): https://mccraygp.com/security-guard-cost/
- McCray, Officer Classification Program (link target confirmed): https://mccraygp.com/officer-classifications/